Jane in the Library
By Jane Alwis, History Teacher, Academic Advisor, and IB Faculty

Teaching AI with Purpose

How Eagle Hill School teaches students to evaluate sources, question texts, and engage in critical thinking.

At Eagle Hill School, we are not afraid to take on new and exciting ideas or address challenges. Some of the questions we have been grappling with over the past year revolve around the use of artificial intelligence. Whatever your thoughts, there is one fact we cannot ignore: AI is here, and our students are going to use it whether we like it or not. There are many questions concerning the use of AI in education:

  • When does AI strengthen teaching and learning—and when does it get in the way?
  • How do we assess authentic student learning in an AI‑mediated world?
  • How do we protect student privacy, safety, and academic integrity?

These are all important concerns, but most importantly: How do we teach students to use AI meaningfully while emphasizing that learning should remain deeply human and personal? At Eagle Hill, we strongly advocate that learning takes place by engaging with information—analyzing, synthesizing, and manipulating it to support a contention or thesis we struggle to formulate. Continued human instruction and oversight are needed to ensure students are engaging meaningfully with the texts in front of them, whether those texts are digital or old‑fashioned words printed on paper.

At Eagle Hill, we strongly advocate that learning takes place by engaging with information—analyzing, synthesizing, and manipulating it to support a contention or thesis we struggle to formulate.

Literacy is about equipping learners with agency and a sense of purpose so they can shape their own lives and contribute meaningfully to the lives of those around them. In today’s digital world, we are surrounded by an increasing volume of quickly generated content, a significant amount of which involves little or no human oversight. Some of it is inaccurate, some of it is biased, and some of it withholds important perspectives readers should know. At Eagle Hill, we teach students to question texts, think critically about who wrote or created the text, how it was created, and why. This entails engaging deeply with each text.

At Eagle Hill, we teach students to question texts, think critically about who wrote or created the text, how it was created, and why. This entails engaging deeply with each text.

The role of the teacher, no matter the subject area, is to guide students in understanding that texts should be evaluated and questioned—to ensure the information available is accurate, unbiased, and trustworthy, which AI often fails to do. The strength of artificial intelligence, especially large language models (LLMs), is to quickly generate answers, summarize documents, and sort data. It is a tool for information retrieval, not a replacement for human judgment, ethics, and curated expertise.

Over the past three years, AI has become ubiquitous, particularly in the information ecosystem. Whether we go online for business, pleasure, or personal need, many websites and apps incorporate AI in ways ranging from subtle to overt. GenAI is not the only tool used, either. Predictive AI also has its impact—from shopping recommendations to website visitation suggestions to streaming recommendations. If there are “recommendations” in the module, AI probably determined them. Although ChatGPT was released three years ago, AI has been in our digital ecosystem much longer, since the 2010s.

“WorkSlop” is both the basis and the product of insufficient research and questionable ethical writing practices. It is the reason classroom educators and librarians will continue to exist as guardians of quality student research and writing. At Eagle Hill, we work closely with students, becoming familiar with the nuances of each student’s writing style and the syntax of their responses, and as such we are better able to guide each in strengthening their authentic voice.

At Eagle Hill, we work closely with students, becoming familiar with the nuances of each student’s writing style and the syntax of their responses, and as such we are better able to guide each in strengthening their authentic voice.

In the past two years, three independent studies exploring student metacognition have emerged from Germany, China, and India. In the studies, groups of student output were compared between those who had access to AI tools such as ChatGPT and editing software and those who did not. All three studies found that students who did not have to struggle to obtain information, who did not engage fully in the selection and evaluation of relevance, and who did not have to think about the editing process had weaker written responses and demonstrated less mastery of information at both the high school and college levels. In other words, those students who did not engage working memory in all three of its natural functions—intrinsic (dealing with the complexity of the material), extraneous (filtering out irrelevant detail and distractions), and germane (processing information and building mental schema to anchor learning)—had less mastery over the material studied. Less metacognitive evaluation led to less mastery.

Eagle Hill Pioneers should become knowledge builders, not just consumers of knowledge—they should be creators of meaning.

So, as a teacher of history, what should I do? AI is here; it is a presence we cannot deny, nor can we ban our students from using it. What I can do is teach responsible use of AI. I can continue to emphasize the human qualities of learning, teach students to develop and defend historical argument, and help them accept that there are multiple perspectives on every issue. Eagle Hill Pioneers should become knowledge builders, not just consumers of knowledge—they should be creators of meaning. Students only learn what they think about; they need to understand that process is more important than product. I need to work with my students to demonstrate and help them understand the importance of researching and evaluating sources to ensure that they are able to adjudicate which sources are viable and which are the product of WorkSlop. There seems to be a general consensus that certain human qualities, like empathy and critical thinking, cannot be replicated by AI, and these are essential elements in education. At Eagle Hill, we encourage our students to develop their own personal ethical guidelines, prioritizing human value over technological capabilities.

The future is not a choice between AI and human ingenuity but should be seen as a partnership between the two.

 

Eagle Hill School's Academic programs:  Learn More >>

 

Learning Diversity Blog icon

Subscribe to our Blog!

Sign up below and receive the 
Learning Diversity Blog sent directly
to your email. 

Sign up >>

 

What is Learning Diversity About?

Learning Diversity is a blog hosted by Eagle Hill School where educators, students, and other members of the LD community regularly contribute posts and critical essays about learning and living in spaces that privilege the inevitability of human diversity.

The contributors of Learning Diversity come together to engage our readers from a variety of disciplines, including the humanities, social sciences, biological sciences and mathematics, athletics, and residential life. Embracing learning diversity means understanding and respecting our students as whole persons.